Hubby and I are planning to go to Caribbean for spring break, in March 2012. We cannot decide whether to go on a cruise or on an all -inclusive vacation. And where exactly in Caribbean to go?
Mexico? Dominican? Puerto Rico or some other islands?
We are in our late twenties, have never been that direction. Budget is a concern too 
Thank you!
Thanks, JustAGirl! Yes, if you would, that be great:)
{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }
Hi Ya
I’ve done both and both have their own unique pluses and minuses.
For a cruise:
Pros
- multiple destinations
- very relaxing with lots to do usually on board
- getting to know other passengers
- shows on board, usually
- usually good food choices or varying places to eat on board
Cons
- minimal time in port could mean that not all that wish to be done get done, rushing to get back to the ship
- package tours offered can be expensive and limited
- days at sea can be restrictive
- can be a restriction on alcoholic drinks
A-I resort
Pros
- food and most if not all alcoholic drinks included
- daily and nightly entertainment
- being able to explore the local area at your own pace
- more choice in excursions
- get to know other visitors
- getting to know a local or two
Cons
- can be convinced that it is not safe to leave the resort (not true in most cases)
- limited food, or food becomes boring after a while
Personally, I didn’t mind the cruise and I would do another one, but I sure do like spending a few days or a week or two in one place so that I can explore, relax, maybe get to know a local or two, take a few trips/excursions,and sample the local culture & food.
Both are good choices….imho I would think it would be more down to seeing multiple destinations or getting to know one place….each are great!
With respect to when you would like to go….well, you will have to see or decide what atmosphere you might like. Most "spring breakers" won’t be on a cruise, where as, Mexico will more then likely have quite a few, especially some place like Cancun. A cruise might also be a bit cheaper but again, you are going to have to do some comparison. You might want to consider a travel agent to help you as they can lay out all your options for you.
Enjoy!
All inclusive is fun. But a cruise can be quite a bit cheaper (unless you are heavy drinkers). I went to Mexico last year for my first all inclusive and I am doing a cruise in a week. I can keep you posted if you would like as to which one I thought was better and why.
fjidoasjdfksalfjkdlas;jf
all-inclusives are great as they cover everything !! If budget is a concern, you will get the most for your money by choosing a place like the Dominican Republic. If I were you, I would rule out Mexico for various, diverse reasons. The Grand Caymans are great along with St. Maarten, Dutch and French all together. Hope you enjoy a wonderful get-away!